I run a small retainer setup for fitness clients and I'm onboarding people one at a time, mostly by hand. It works but I can't take on many more without it eating my week. Before I go changing things I want to know what the variable actually is — is it the intake, the first week, or the check-ins? For those of you running membership or community setups: what did you change in onboarding that moved retention, and what did it cost you in time? I'd rather hear the trade-off than a template.
Member onboarding — what actually works at low volume?
Discussion
- Purpose
- Find out which part of onboarding is worth rebuilding first when your own hours are the constraint.
6 replies
Audience: Public. Replies follow this audience.
0Jun ChuaPortfolio Operator · productised serviceSingapore·Established Solo·6d ago
When you say "onboarding" — do you mean the first session, the first 30 days, or the whole ramp until someone's self-sufficient? I ask because I fixed the wrong end of that for about a year and it cost me money. Once I knew the actual drop-off point, the rest was quick to sort.
0Angelo MendozaNewsletter Writer · paid newsletterPhilippines·Scaling·6d ago
Great that you're protecting the first week — that's usually where the value impression is set. I write a weekly newsletter for paying subscribers and the honest answer is my onboarding is still mostly me. Which is fine, until it isn't.
0Refilwe BothaExecutive Coach · group programmeSouth Africa·Early Revenue·6d ago
I onboarded eight people into a group programme. The thing that helped most was telling them exactly what happens in week one. Not a welcome pack — one message. Then I called each one on day two. Four minutes each. Churn dropped. Small sample, I know.
0Mason MercerCareer Coach · 1:1 coachingUnited States·Exploring·6d ago
Just charge more and take fewer of them. If your calendar is the bottleneck, the problem isn't onboarding, it's price.
0Eoin ByrnePortfolio Operator · paid newsletterIreland·Scaling·6d ago
Two things worked for us. Send the first win inside 48 hours — something they can point at. And cap the intake form at four questions. We added a fifth and completion fell off a cliff; took it back out the same week. Don't know if that holds for a retainer model, it was built for a paid list.
0Bianca MendozaContent Strategist · retainer consultingPhilippines·Established Solo·6d ago
The uncomfortable part is that hand-holding is the product for the first month, so automating it early removes the thing people paid for. I'd pick one step to cut — the scheduling back-and-forth, probably — and leave the calls alone.
Building a business around what you know?
The Network is free to join. Ask your own questions, answer others, and find people doing the same work.
See the Network