Three years back I was convinced my content strategy work would sell itself as a €12k productized engagement. I built the pitch, diagram, the whole thing. Sent it to 47 people who'd been on my list longer than a year. Four replies total. Nobody bought. I'd assumed 'audience = buyers'. Wrong. The people who did want help needed three calls before they'd even tell me their budget. If I could redo it: smaller offer first, €900 sprint, done in a week. Then scale. What I still don't have is the proof buyers ask for — nobody sees results they can point at. So my question: how do you build proof when the clients you want are the ones who want proof before they'll start?
My €12k offer nobody bought (and what I should have done)
Case study
Author-reported results.
- Starting situation
- Had 3+ years of newsletter, 2,000 subscribers, and a clear method (content operating system for B2B founders). Kept getting 'love your stuff!' DMs but no path to a paid offer.
- What changed
- Packaged the whole system into a €12k productized engagement: audit, 12-week rollout, monthly reporting. Sent to 47 past newsletter engagers via personal Loom. Four replies, zero sales.
- Result
- Replies said 'interesting, timing is off' or asked for a case study I didn't have. One guy said 'I'd try it for €800 to see if you can actually do it.' I said no. In hindsight, I should have said yes. Now building a €900 one-week sprint as the entry point.
- Limitations
- This doesn't prove €900 is the right number for everyone. It proves *I* had no proof and expected buyers to take on all the risk. The bigger mistake was waiting three years to build any proof artefact. Also: my audience was readers, not buyers. Different list, different offer.
6 replies
Audience: Public. Replies follow this audience.
0Thabo MokoenaBlogger · self-paced courseSouth Africa·Established Solo·5d ago
Question first — when you say 'audience was readers not buyers', was that a positioning issue or a list quality issue? Because the fix is different. If it's list quality, no offer size fixes it. If it's positioning, your €900 sprint might.
0Arjun JoshiLegal Educator · productised serviceIndia·Scaling·5d ago
I did the same. Sent a €10k retainer to 60 warm leads. Nothing. Dropped to €1,200, still nothing. What worked was a €400 'diagnostic call + written plan' — sold 9 in six weeks. That gave me the case studies to sell the €10k later. Don't skip the small rung.
0Anika WhakataneProductivity Coach · Digital Product EntrepreneursNew Zealand·Growing Team·5d ago
I think what you're really describing isn't an offer problem, it's a follow-up problem. I had the same pattern — great first calls, then nothing. What changed for me was batching follow-ups into three touches max and putting a real deadline on the second one. Not fake urgency, but 'I'm taking two more this month'. I know that's not what you asked. But you said four replies from 47. That's not an offer issue, that's a list that was never actually warm. Separate the two before you rebuild the offer. Because if you rebuild the offer and the list is still cold, you'll get the same result, just cheaper.
0Fletcher BlackwoodBusiness Consultant · Independent ConsultantsAustralia·Early Revenue·5d ago
Wait — 47 people and you personalised each Loom? That's a lot of hours for zero feedback. Did anyone tell you why they didn't buy? I've found the 'why not' is worth more than the sale.
0Kagiso KhumaloFinancial Coach · self-paced courseSouth Africa·Early Revenue·5d ago
The €900 sprint is the right instinct. Small enough to say yes. Big enough to matter.
0Lena WeberLanguage Tutor · productised serviceGermany·Early Revenue·5d ago
Following. I'm at the exact same stage and this is the first honest version of this I've seen.
Building a business around what you know?
The Network is free to join. Ask your own questions, answer others, and find people doing the same work.
See the Network